Celebrating 50 years of publishing a Radical Journal of Geography, 1969-2019
“On December 14-15, 2013, at a programme called Do Din (‘two days’), we will be speaking out about Bholakpur’s role in the city. Not just in this city but in the whole world. People assume that Bholakpur is a polluted area. But the truth is that we at Bholakpur take the pollution and toxins of the whole city and we recover value from it for the world. We provide revenue for the government and we want to world to know who we are and what we do…” (Chand Munawar, Bholakpur resident, speaking on YouTube here)
The project ‘A Spatial Political Economy of Waste in Hyderabad, India: A “Geography From Below” Approach’ aimed to build the spatial history of Bholakpur, a historic inner-city neighbourhood of Hyderabad with a 300-year-old mosque at its centre and a thriving scrap market all around it. The area has been under threat of eviction in recent years as the old leather processing economy withered away and scrap recycling has grown. Under these circumstances, four researchers – Anant Maringanti, Vamsi Vakulabharanam, Poornima Chikarmane and Siddharth Hande – collaborated with the aid of a grant from the Antipode Foundation disbursed through the University of Hyderabad to work towards the following goals:
1. Building a dynamic, collaborative counter-mapping and multimedia platform online;
2. Creating a popular educational aid challenging mainstream narratives of place, and a policy brief that analyses urban processes from below; and
3. Writing two or more academic and semi-academic articles on the place-based economic and cultural geographies of urban waste.
Our goal, from the beginning, was to use the project as an avenue to generate resources that could have multiple uses. In other words, a careful consideration of the ‘afterlives’ of the project was central to the vision. The project entailed bringing together expertise in information technology, open and collaborative spatial data technologies, community mobilization, social sciences and humanities, and communication media, to be blended with radical geography to illuminate that which mainstream accounts of the city efface and provide a counter-narrative of Hyderabad’s urban processes from the vantage point of Bholakpur’s residents. It seeks not only to contribute to the urban studies literature on Indian cities, but also – and equally important – to aid the residents
of places like Bholakpur to represent the true value of their contributions to Hyderabad’s economy and ecology, while simultaneously identifying ways to reduce the risks they bear in managing the city’s waste.
Over the course of the project, we built deep linkages with the community of scrap traders and workers through collaborative mapping workshops, focus group discussions and survey-based quantitative data collection. As each of these was done with an open-ended approach, the outputs far exceeded the original plan. For example, the mapping platform which went through an iterative process of design became available to a variety of communities and researchers interested in mapping biodiversity, public transit and environmental sanitation helping us to create databases that can be used for a range of community mobilization activities. The media, particularly newspapers, took an active interest in the project and published several articles on the politics of waste, the potential of mapping technologies, and popular geography (see, for example, here). A popular theatre group in the city worked with the residents of Bholakpur to produce an hour-long play; it can be watched online here.
Plans for the future
We faced challenges in the design of a collaborative multimedia and mapping platform, and still have not fully resolved the question of how best to build something open-ended. After several iterations, we settled somewhat uncomfortably on a MediaWiki platform because it allows us to generate content on the fly, giving the freedom to alter the taxonomies as we go; the alpha version is available here. As the interactive platform develops, we hope it will serve as a resource for both academic researchers and community organizers, able to submit, and put to work, geo-tagged images, audio recordings, and text to represent and challenge places of ‘value’ and risk in the city.
Our relationship with Bholakpur communities transformed from one of wariness in the beginning to one of active engagement on the questions related to housing and safety and state-led planning processes. As we began the project, we knew that building enduring relationships of trust is a long-term process. Why should the people of Bholakpur trust a group of academic researchers? We ran into people stonewalling us with “we don’t really expect you to do any good for us; we just want to be sure that you do not cause any damage…”. Indeed, the relationship between social scientists and communities was already structured through a particular idiom. As one of the traders, who in time became a strong supporter, said at first “I dont really understand this need to actually know the truth. You collect data, you write a paper and you get your certificate. Why is it important to get the data to reflect the reality?”. Ten months into the project, the same person said to us “Now I understand what it means when you say, that this kind of work can actually bring us some good”.
The project also facilitated an MPhil thesis (shortly due for submission by a student at the University of Hyderabad).
Our Antipode Scholar-Activist Project Award provided critical support for a small initiative to take off and grow in multiple directions without losing sight of the modest goals with which it all began. The resources generated in the project are currently being developed in three directions: [i] a place-based critique of the spatial ontology of masterplanning approaches in India; [ii] a political-economic investigation into the circuits of waste; and [iii] a series of educational modules both for higher education programmes in law, planning and urban studies, and for ‘Right to the City’ activists.